AMPAC Study Board (186)

Here is a full study guide built directly from the material you provided — structured, comprehensive, and ready for learning. I’ve organized it into clear sections, added key terms, timelines, case law, and conceptual breakdowns. Guided Links are included so you can dive deeper into any topic you want next.

 

Study Guide: State Continuity, Succession, and the Kingdom of Morocco

 

I. Core Concepts in International Law

A. State Continuity

A State continues to exist even if its government, territory, or population changes. James Crawford: continuity exists as long as an identifiable polity remains over a significant part of territory and people.

B. State Succession

One State replaces another in responsibility for a territory and population. Examples: decolonization, dissolution of Yugoslavia, USSR breakup.

C. The Debate: Continuity vs. Succession

  • Crawford: distinction is real and essential.

  • Brownlie, Craven, O’Connell: distinction is overly political and confusing.

  • Craven: “legal personality” alone cannot determine continuity vs. succession.

  • O’Connell: priority should be preserving obligations, not identity.

 

II. Morocco’s Legal Status After 1956

  • Indépendance Du Maroc Pdf : Indépendance du Maroc : Histoire et lutte ...
     
  • Création du Maroc indépendant - Mars 1956
     
  • Protectorate Countries
     
  • Spanish and French Protectorate - Colonization of Morocco
     

A. Requirement Under UN Charter Article 102

A State cannot declare itself sovereign without transparent registration of its legal status with the UN Secretariat.

B. Morocco’s Possible Post‑1956 Status

  1. Succession State

  2. Successor State

  3. Continuity State (Presumption)

Morocco did not formally register a continuity claim after independence.

 

III. ICJ Case: Rights of Nationals of the United States in Morocco (1952)

  • 国际法院裁定:美国针对某些伊朗资产的冻结举措不合法 | | 1联合国新闻
     
  • What is the International Court of Justice? – Civilsdaily
     
  • International Court of Justice (ICJ) | Definition, Cases, Purpose ...
     
  • International Court Of Justice
     

Key Issue

Whether the U.S. could claim jurisdictional rights in Morocco based on the most‑favored‑nation clause.

Important Passage (from your document)

“The United States… still treats Morocco as a single country… entitled under the most‑favoured‑nation clause… to the same jurisdictional rights which Great Britain today exercises in a part of Morocco…”

Significance

  • Confirms Morocco was treated as one territorial entity even under divided French/Spanish zones.

  • Shows how foreign powers viewed Moroccan sovereignty before 1956.

 

IV. Madrid Convention of 1880 — Article 15(1)

Historical Rule

A Moroccan subject naturalized abroad returning to Morocco must:

  • Choose full submission to Moroccan law, OR

  • Leave Morocco, unless naturalization was approved by Morocco.

Modern Status

  • Article 15(1) is obsolete.

  • No current Moroccan statute implements this “choice mechanism.”

  • Modern nationality law is governed by the Moroccan Nationality Code (1958, amended 2007).

 

V. Vienna Convention on Succession of States in Respect of Treaties (1978)

  • The Protocol and NGO Liaison Office of the United Nations Office at ...
     
  • Vienna International Center - a photo on Flickriver
     
  • United Nations | Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
     
  • US condemns Iran's vice president role at UN nuclear treaty conference ...
     

Timeline

  • 1967–1974 — ILC drafts articles

  • 31 July–23 Aug 1978 — UN Conference in Vienna

  • 23 Aug 1978 — Convention adopted

  • 6 Nov 1996 — Entered into force

Key Article for Morocco Context: Article 34

When part of a State separates to form new States:

  • Treaties continue for successor States unless incompatible with treaty purpose.

 

VI. Amazigh (Berber) People and Moroccan Constitutional Law

  • Kabyle Flag Amazigh Flag Round Pin (Amazigh, Berber, Kabyle) | EBay
     
  • Amazigh Flag
     
  • Amazighen -The Haha Berbers | Alphabet amazigh, Apprendre l'alphabet ...
     
  • Yennayer: Celebrating the Amazigh New Year and Traditions - Arab America
     

A. Citizenship

Amazigh people are full Moroccan citizens by birth. They are the indigenous population of Morocco.

B. 1996 Constitutional Amendments

The 1996 Constitution did NOT make Tamazight an official language. However, it introduced:

  • Preamble: Morocco’s identity includes Arabic, Islamic, Amazigh, and Sahara Hassani components.

  • Article 9: Freedom of expression, association — enabling Amazigh cultural activism.

  • Article 13: Equal access to education and employment.

C. 2011 Constitution (Major Change)

  • Article 5: Tamazight becomes an official language of Morocco.

  • Recognition of Amazigh identity as part of national heritage.

 

VII. Morocco–Amazigh Relations After 1956

A. No New Treaties After Independence

Post‑1956 Morocco did not sign formal treaties with Amazigh tribes.

B. State Strategy Instead

  • Centralization of authority

  • Administrative integration

  • Military presence in tribal regions

  • Economic development projects (roads, schools, markets)

C. Political Developments

  • 1956–1959: Amazigh uprisings

  • Rise of Amazigh political parties

  • Monarchy consolidates power over nationalist parties

D. Cultural Reforms Under King Mohammed VI

  • 2001: Royal Institute of Amazigh Culture (IRCAM) created

  • Expansion of Amazigh media, education, cultural rights

E. Land Rights Issues (2018–2019)

New laws allowed sale/lease of soulaliyate (collective) lands. Amazigh activists argue this threatens traditional communal governance.

 

VIII. Key Scholars and Theories

A. James Crawford

  • Distinguishes continuity vs. succession

  • Focuses on statehood criteria rather than legal personality

B. Ian Brownlie

  • Says distinction is overly political

C. Matthew Craven

  • Legal personality cannot determine continuity/succession

D. O’Connell

  • Prioritizes preserving obligations

  • Continuity should be assumed to maintain legal certainty

 

IX. Practice Questions

Short Answer

  1. Define State continuity and give one example.

  2. What is Article 15(1) of the Madrid Convention?

  3. Why did the 1996 Moroccan Constitution matter for Amazigh identity?

  4. What major change occurred in 2011 regarding Tamazight?

  5. Explain the difference between a successor State and a continuity State.

Essay Prompts

  1. Compare Crawford’s constitutionalist approach to O’Connell’s private‑law approach.

  2. Analyze Morocco’s post‑1956 legal status using UN Charter Article 102.

  3. Discuss how Amazigh identity evolved in Moroccan constitutional law from 1956–2011.

 

X. Key Takeaways

  • Morocco’s post‑1956 legal identity is debated: continuity vs. succession.

  • Article 15(1) of the Madrid Convention is obsolete today.

  • Amazigh people are full citizens; Tamazight became an official language in 2011.

  • No post‑1956 treaties were signed with Amazigh tribes; integration occurred through administration and development.

  • State continuity debates center on identity, sovereignty, and legal obligations.

 

» The L.A.W. of the Empire of Morocco